KATA BUNKAI: IAIN ABERNETHY vs. JESSE ENKAMP
In a captivating video on YouTube, Jesse Enkamp, known as “The Karate Nerd,” challenges Sensei Ian Abernathy, a respected UK expert on practical kata applications. The video, uploaded on March 26th, 2018, has attracted thousands of viewers, making it a popular choice among martial arts enthusiasts.
The video commences with Enkamp demonstrating a karate technique taken from the kata, the solo forms practiced in karate. The focus is on the Mikazuki Geri, which means Crescent kick or Halfmoon kick. Interested in Abernathy’s interpretation of this technique for self-defense purposes, Enkamp serves him a Bunkai challenge.
Sensei Abernathy offers insight on this movement in different forms and explains how every part is essential in a practical application. He lays out three potential scenarios that could follow the kick: a straightforward takedown of the enemy, an advantageous spin to take the enemy down if the original technique hadn’t worked, and a scenario where the technique hasn’t worked at all, requiring immediate movement and a strike for escape.
As the video transitions to colder surroundings in Sweden, Enkamp then takes his turn to discuss his technique, the “returning wave kick.” Highlighting two key considerations, time and space, Enkamp details how different moves can combine to create a sophisticated self-defense strategy. He not only demonstrates the movement but also explains how it might be applied in real-life situations.
Enkamp and Abernathy’s engaging exchange of techniques and applications invites viewers to learn and participate, making the video a must-watch for every karate enthusiast. Their differing approaches, blended with their shared passion for the discipline, demonstrate the beauty and complexity of this martial art. The video concludes with a call to viewers to vote on their preferred approach in the comments, fostering a strong sense of community among followers.
Check out the video to gain a deeper understanding of the intricacies of karate and appreciate the work of these two dedicated martial arts professionals. Enjoy the journey of mastering self-defense techniques and always remember: Train hard, good luck, and have fun.
[postx_template id=”84″]
Jesse Enkamp: A Karate Master
Jesse Enkamp, often known as The Karate Nerd, is a renowned Karate expert and educator. From a young age, Jesse has demonstrated extraordinary commitment to mastering his craft, and has risen to become a well-recognized figure in the world of martial arts. His approach to teaching, blends traditional techniques with modern scientific methods. This unique approach has earned Jesse thousands of followers around the globe. Moreover, Jesse’s passion for Karate is not confined to teaching alone – he has also authored numerous books and articles, sharing his extensive knowledge and experiences with the world.
[postx_template id=”177″]
Practical Karate Applications in MMA and Fighting Sports
In the world of MMA and other fighting sports, practical Karate applications play a vital role. With its systematic strength training, Karate has proved itself to be a competent martial art that can stand against other combat styles.
Combat Efficiency
Karate’s practical applications predominantly reside in its strikes and kicks that can quickly incapacitate an opponent. The speed and precision this discipline promotes are held in high regard within the MMA realm.
However, the philosophical principles of Karate are often overlooked in the MMA context. In MMA, the focus is on physical prowess, while Karate emphasizes both physical and spiritual development. As such, Karate is not only a practical combat style, but also a way of continuous personal growth.
[postx_template id=”85″]
The Legacy of Japanese Martial Arts
The Japanese martial arts, like Karate and Judo, have a rich history tracing back centuries. Originally, they were not merely self-defense techniques but also a way of life, integrating elements of philosophy and spirituality. They evolved into tools for physical training, discipline, and character building.
Thanks for everyone's AWESOME comments! 🙂 Visit my website to learn more about Karate: http://www.karatebyjesse.com
i actually liked both bunkai.
That crescent kick at the star! I do Taekwondo and I have never seen anybody throw a crescent kick that fast!
Great Application by BOTH because of the Emphasis on Principles and Reactions no Literal interpretation of assumed complete actions ans set response
For me, Naihanchi has always been a grappling kata. This was reinforced when I started BJJ and to me, this move is almost exactly a leg hook takedown from a clinch, you can see many Gracies use this in early UFC’s.
Sensei Abernathy and Sensei Enkamp both have extremely high energy levels, almost explosive. Yet they have both mastered their Self, so that this explosive energy is consistently expressed in a positive way.
Subtitles for
Funakoshi : fun of coffee
Naihanchi or Tekki : the hunter your techie
Kata : cotton
Ok
Well done Karate nerd colleague! Indeed there are some more aplications for this kick. You can kick the knees, kidneys, hook the oponents head, disarm the guard, etc…
Not everyone wears a karate uniform in the street but they used to all wear kimonos/yukatas which are basically the same design. All the grabs and chokes WERE practical back then due to the clothe they wore but not now. Everything evolves, and I am kinda glad that no gi became a thing in other martial arts.
Abernathy scores
I liked both interpretations, but analysing katas to figure out what they might be for is just so backwards…
This is such a great opportunity to get insight from two devoted practitioners. Honestly think we the viewers really do win. Now if I had to pick one in this instance I choose Sensei Jesse due to detailed simplicity. Idk maybe he made it easy for you? Maybe do best out of three?
Hi, i chose Jesse's channel to learn english, and i dont practice karate already many years. but i like it, and this channel is more funny then textbooks. So I vote Jesse, because Iain speaks terribly fast.
nice effect, now I'm going to the jail!
I think I prefer Jesse's.
2022 and I think we need a new bunkai challenge video 😁🥋
Bloody ruddy
Both are great interpretations. I really enjoy learning from you two. Thank you!
I have to say here. Interesting for sure, but I do get tired of hearing “you can’t kick high in self defence” use what works is my motto, I’ve been in bad situations and I’ve used high kicks and they worked just fine. I understand that a lot of people can’t kick high fast and with power, but some people can. A well timed high kick has just as much potential to work as anything else. Cheers, love the content.
🤔💡👌🏻
This is four years old, but I still wanted to comment: well done both of you! These really present unique learning templates on how to breath new meaning and life into our own practice. To choose one over the other is not possible. I am convinced that kata are meant to impart (at least) three things. The first level is physical fitness, the second level is to document specific techniques, the third and final level (if there is a final level) is how to move in a balanced and focused way reacting to whatever may be occurring at the time. The actual techniques are just the vehicle to practice and learn. Thank you again for the wonderful insights you both so tirelessly share to all.
I think both bunkais were awesome, but my vote is going for te first demonstration because i think its more simple in a danger situation, and te Idea of plan a, b and c is really cool, but both bunkais were great!
More please, thank you. 🙂
Impossible to decide. Both were brilliant. More of this!
Great !!! Thanks a lot for this interesting video …. 👊🇻🇪
A big greeting from Argentina to both Masters.